Faculty Votes to Revise Pass/Fail Policy
Starting July 2027, students will have to declare their intention to pass/fail a course by the end of the add/drop period and may pass/fail up to two courses during their Amherst College career. The change reflects a shift back to the pass/fail policy in place before Covid.
On Friday, faculty voted 123 to 3 to revise the pass/fail policy. Currently, students can opt to pass/fail for up to four classes and have until the final exam period to declare this decision. Starting in July 2027, students will be limited to two total pass/fail uses and will have to declare use of the policy by the end of the add/drop period.
Winkley Professor of History and Political Economy and chair of the Committee on Education Policy Jen Manion presented the proposed changes at the faculty meeting, stating that the CEP decided to reevaluate the pass/fail policy to “[restore] it to its original purpose and structure.” The proposed policy marks a return to an older policy in place prior to the Covid pandemic. Manion said the goal of this return is to “encourage curricular exploration” and to “change the college culture around grading and to redefine feedback as a crucial part of the learning process.”
Manion stated that under the current pass/fail policy — a more lenient version introduced in 2019 to maximize intellectual risk-taking — most students end up declaring pass/fail late in the term, contributing to stressful conversations between students and faculty about “the best place to use the pass/fail option.” They proceeded to present two scenarios, one a student who is trying to avoid the “dreaded A-,” the other genuinely struggling with the material, perhaps due to extenuating circumstances. Manion acknowledged that most faculty would want to support the latter student, but also encouraged faculty to consider the similarities in these two situations: Both students are given the message that “some grades aren’t worth getting” and an option to “write off a course at any point in the semester,” and faculty are asked to weigh in on what grade the student is likely to end up with. Class deans are also not consulted in the process.
“I’ve been told that these conversations can be particularly fraught and stressful, both for the student and for the faculty member … that if you encourage the student to go for it, that somehow it is your responsibility to ensure that they get the grades they thought they wanted,” Manion said. They proceeded to state that what the CEP wanted to achieve with the proposed policy is a disentanglement of the policy’s emergency use in extenuating circumstances from its original point, as well as a shift in college culture that redefines feedback as a crucial part of the learning process rather than “a nuisance to be managed or avoided.”
“It proposes that effective feedback, even if occasionally less laudatory than one would like, is itself a form of academic support and engagement,” Manion said. They added that the proposed policy does not change or minimize the ability of class deans to advise students in crisis who need individual course withdrawals or medical leave.
During their presentation, Manion presented data on pass/fail use by course divisions and levels over the past two years, citing that science and math courses in the 100 and 200-levels saw the most pass/fail uses. Manion also presented data on whether students are using pass/fail to “take classes outside of their division or comfort zone,” noting that “the majority of the humanities majors who are exercising pass/fail are doing [so] in another humanities course,” and that there is a similar pattern among STEM majors.
Manion concluded their presentation by likening the current policy to “Coke II,” a failed attempt to redesign the classic Coca-Cola, and the proposed new policy to “Coke Classic,” eliciting a wave of laughter among the faculty.
William J. Walker Professor of Mathematics Rob Benedetto, a former chair of the CEP who was involved in the drafting and implementation of the current pass/fail policy, described the policy as an “experiment” that proved “a spectacular failure.” “I would strongly encourage us to go back to Coke Classic,” he said.
Dean of New Students and Professor of American Studies Kiara Vigil suggested further discussion for the policy around course withdrawal, proposing to extend the deadline for course withdrawal from the end of the 10th week of the semester to the last eight classes. This discussion has been postponed to a follow-up conversation.
Upon some further questioning of how many students declare pass/fail early in the semester, Director of Institutional Research and Registrar Services Jesse Barba stated that almost all students do so in the week before finals. The faculty moved to call the question after around five minutes of discussion, and voted in overwhelming favor of the proposal.
Comments ()