Professor Speaks on War on Drugs and Masculinities

García-Reyes challenged the “binary logic” of the drug war where traffickers are presented as violent and the state as protectors of good citizens, arguing that both sides perpetuate violence through a hypermasculine behavior logic.

Professor Speaks on War on Drugs and Masculinities
García-Reyes interviewed 33 former drug traffickers at an evangelical rehabilitation center in Mexico for her research. Photo courtesy of Amherst College.

On Tuesday, the Sexuality, Women and Gender Studies department hosted Dr. Karina García-Reyes, a senior lecturer in criminology at the University of the West of England (UWE Bristol), for a talk on the intersection of masculinities and the global war on drugs at Pruyne Lecture Hall. There was significant interest in the event, with a majority of seats in the lecture hall filled and considerable audience interaction with García-Reyes throughout. 

She opened her talk by asking the audience to name characteristics associated with “real men,” with attendees offering responses such as “strong,” “provider,” and “protector.” García-Reyes asked them to keep this list in mind as the talk continued, which would prove central to her argument in regard to how hypermasculinity shapes both drug traffickers and state policy meant to stop them. 

García-Reyes hails from Saltillo in the Mexican state of Coahuila, where she conducted research at an evangelical rehabilitation center to construct her paper, “The ‘Real Man’ in the Global War on Drugs: Narco versus Militarised Masculinities.” Her visit to the center allowed her to engage with 33 former drug traffickers through life story interviews. She noted her position as a woman in the interviews because, she said, “in qualitative studies … we have to reflect on our personality in the data we collect.” She said that the men more openly discussed their actions and motives without viewing her as a threat to their masculinity. “They were very confident in crying in front of me … they didn’t feel the need to impress another man,” García-Reyes said. However, she added, “they were not equally confident in sharing, for example, details about sexual violence.”

A central aspect of her argument revolved around the hierarchy of masculinities drawn from sociologist Raewyn Connell. According to García-Reyes, the hegemonic, “aspirational model” for men is “based on strength [and] emotional suppression.” She places militarized masculinity at the top of the hierarchy, as hegemonic and complicit, whilst narcos are considered marginalized. “Marginalized masculinities are excluded either because of their class [or] because of their race,” she said. However, upon comparison, “militarized” and “narcos” hold very similar positions, with identical traits like aggression, emotional suppression, and heterosexuality. The major defining difference was the militarized emphasis on self-discipline.

She challenged the “binary logic” of the drug war where traffickers are presented as violent monsters and the state as protectors of good citizens. “I challenge the fact that only criminals, the narcos, are made responsible for the human costs of the war on drugs.” García-Reyes argued that while narcos play a key role in producing violence, “it is a super masculine state through a militarized policy that perpetuates the horrors of the war.” 

She described the differences between police and military force, differentiating between the police being “trained to protect the citizens” and the military being “trained to kill the enemy.” When attendees were asked how they felt about military presence, a student from Washington, D.C. shared their perspective on the National Guard deployment, saying it made them feel uncomfortable and less safe. “Whenever the military is deployed in the streets, something is wrong. That should be the exception, and we have made it a rule,” she said. 

The lecture was followed by a Q&A, where students asked questions regarding alternative approaches to a “War on Drugs.” García-Reyes described the most important harm reduction approach, saying that “instead of prohibition, the government should go back to a health approach in which those having issues with misuse or addiction of drugs should be offered support from the health department, not criminalizing the subject.”

She also highlighted the role of “transnational business masculinities” in the Global North steering global drug policy. Defined by the way it “often inflicts horrific violence from a distance on increasingly large scales,” García-Reyes explained how this form of masculinity is often excluded from the conversation. “We rarely think about those at the top that make decisions that affect the lives and the deaths of millions of people in the Global South,” she said. 

Beyond this, many attendees raised important questions about the role of women in the drug trafficking process. García-Reyes originally planned to interview both men and women but found it difficult to build rapport with women interviewees. While the men were more comfortable with sharing, she found questioning women about violence more complex. “[Men] were comfortable sharing how powerful they were once, because who would question a man for being violent? … When it comes to the women, we would question a woman who put her child in danger,” she said.

She pointed to differing gender expectations, as men open up about past violence because traditional societal standards expect them to be aggressive. Women in the trade exploit stereotypes of themselves as “weak and naive” to be less suspected by police and the criminal justice system. “They took advantage of the image that the men have of them for their own benefit,” she said. 

Another question in the session focused on how hypermasculinity in government can be addressed. García-Reyes called for a shift. “I think we need less hypermasculine individuals in power,” she said. “More feminist politicians, less masculine individuals.” 

Currently, García-Reyes is working with researchers from Mexico and the University of Oxford in England on an interdisciplinary project that uses new technologies to help local governments and search groups locate clandestine graves in Mexico.