Letter to the Editor: One Part Must Change

Willard Long Thorp Professor of Economics Jessica Wolpaw Reyes argues that any discussion of Amherst admissions is incomplete without addressing recruited athletics and the inequalities that the system perpetuates.

To the Editor:

The article “Dean of Admissions Discusses 2030 Demographics” reports thoughtful endeavors and heartening improvements in the composition of the student body along multiple dimensions.

The article also includes a paragraph that begins “One part of the admissions process remains unchanged: The admissions office has not integrated the use of [artificial intelligence] (AI).” But the most important part that hasn’t changed is something else entirely. A more honest description would read: “The admissions office continues a segregated, bifurcated process, admitting two-thirds of students through the rigorous official process and one-third through an earlier and less rigorous athletics recruitment process that amplifies privilege.”

Athletics recruitment is not a small part of the admissions story, but a full third. The football and men’s lacrosse teams alone constitute almost one-sixth of men on campus. Recruited athletes represent around two-thirds of the early decision cohort, and they are essentially promised admission via summer “pre-read.” Doing some simple math, this means that once actual early decision comes around in the fall, everyone else is likely competing for only about 50 spots. Given the reality that the recruited athlete population is much whiter, wealthier, and more male, this produces and maintains a cascading web of privilege in admissions and in campus life.

How then, is it possible that the above article does not include the words “athlete” or “athletics” anywhere? It’s like describing the trajectory of a thrown ball but omitting gravity, or American inequality omitting racism. It doesn’t make a lot of sense, and it doesn’t add up.  Could this journalistic omission be at least partially connected to the reduction in space and resources for the student newspaper at Amherst? There are, of course, hearty traditions of controlling the press to control the narrative.

The college’s robust and unwavering commitment to the athletics admissions process is a robust and unwavering commitment to maintaining white privilege, wealth privilege, and male privilege.  

One part of the admissions process must change. And it’s not AI.

Jessica Wolpaw Reyes

Willard Long Thorp Professor of Economics