The Color-Line is Still a Problem
Staff Writer Rizwan Ayub ’27 confronts modern-day racial segregation in America, arguing that while legal racial segregation is officially outlawed, its effects are still shown in American cities today through economic inequalities that stem from past legislation rooted in white racism.
The fact that Americans are divided politically today is so widely known that it’s become something of a cultural trope, one epitomized by the stereotype of the “Republican Uncle who makes Thanksgiving uncomfortable for everyone else.” And there is a substantial amount of truth to this claim. Political scientists and pollsters have found that median Democratic and Republican voters have both shifted away from the political center in recent years. Americans also increasingly live in their own political echo chambers, a trend exacerbated by social media. This shift is so profound that, according to The New York Times, which mapped voting patterns from the 2020 election, Democrats and Republicans tend to congregate around each other, and many Americans live in neighborhoods surrounded by neighbors of the same partisan affiliation.
However, focusing exclusively on partisan divides, as much of the relevant media and academia has done, obscures a much more insidious dividing line in America today, that being that the vast majority of American cities are incredibly racially segregated. This is not a new problem. W.E.B. Du Bois, in his seminal 1903 book “The Souls of Black Folk,” remarked that “the problem of the twentieth century is the problem of the color-line,” in that different races were physically separated not just in the Jim Crow South, but across all aspects of American life, both in the North and the South. Unfortunately, despite the progress in fighting racism and de jure segregation brought by the Civil Rights Movement, Du Bois’ “color-line” is still a substantial dividing line in American life even today.
Chicago provides a useful illustration of what de facto segregation looks like today. Census data from the 2020 Census says that Chicago is about 36% white, 30% Latino, and 28% Black. However, these groups are not evenly distributed across the city. Mapping the city’s racial demographics reveals intense racial disparities. According to WTTW, Chicago’s local public broadcaster, the city’s North Side is overwhelmingly white, the South Side is overwhelmingly Black, and the West Side is overwhelmingly Latino. And according to demographic maps of the city’s racial composition created by WTTW, some parts of the city’s South Side have almost no white residents, and the opposite is true for the North Side.
Though Chicago is a particularly intense example of modern-day racial segregation, it is far from the only racially segregated American city. In 2015, The New York Times mapped patterns of urban racial segregation, and across every city they mapped, they found these racial mosaics. From Atlanta to Philadelphia to Los Angeles, Black Americans, whites, Hispanics, and Asians live separately from each other. Similarly, researchers from UC Berkeley’s Othering and Belonging Institute found in 2021 that American cities are, in fact, even more segregated than they were in 1990. This segregation is not a historical accident. Rather, the disparities we see today are the direct result of the legacies of both governmental action and white racism aimed at Black Americans.
This is an incredibly complicated history, but I will try my best to distill it in a few paragraphs. During the Great Depression, the Home Owners’ Loan Corporation, a New Deal program designed to promote homeownership, systematically prevented minorities from accessing credit to buy homes by redlining whole areas —mostly low-income and majority-minority neighborhoods — as “unsafe” to lend to. This practice became colloquially known as “Redlining.” Redlining came coupled with racial covenants, which were clauses in housing contracts that prevented buyers from selling to Black people. Together, these two policies prevented Black Americans from being able to move into predominantly white neighborhoods, buy property, and build up generational wealth. Then, in the 1950s, the designers of the Interstate Highway System intentionally destroyed integrated urban neighborhoods in order to make way for segregated suburban developments.
For instance, in the Bronx, the Cross-Bronx Expressway went directly through racially integrated neighborhoods, and white residents were able to use the highway to flee to the suburbs. Many minority residents were not able to enjoy the benefits of suburbanization because banks would not loan to them. This same pattern played itself out across the U.S., from Boston to Los Angeles. Then, when the Supreme Court ended legally enforced school segregation in its Brown v. Board of Education Decision, busing programs faced “massive resistance” in both the South and the North.
In the South, one form this resistance took was Segregation Academies, when counties closed their public schools entirely, and families instead attended all-white private schools. In the North, Boston’s attempts to desegregate its school system in the 1970s were met with massive amounts of racist violence from white residents, such as when white residents attacked school buses with Black children. Then, in 1974, Milliken v. Bradley struck down federal courts’ ability to impose multi-district desegregation, which effectively throttled school desegregation efforts. This court ruling has helped result in the situation today where, according to NPR, “roughly 9 million children” attend “schools that are racially isolated and receive far less money than schools a few miles today.”
So then, where are we left today? Today, legal racial segregation has been outlawed for over 60 years by the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and other acts. However, most American cities today suffer from what I call “racialized socioeconomic segregation,” or the problem of there being immense socioeconomic disparities between mostly minority neighborhoods and mostly white neighborhoods in American cities today. Generally, Black Americans have suffered immensely because of racialized socioeconomic segregation.
When contrasted, two Chicago neighborhoods, Streeterville and Englewood, provide a jarring example of what this looks like in practice. In 2020, The Guardian compared the two neighborhoods, which are only eight miles away from each other, and reported on how in predominantly white and wealthy Streeterville, residents have a life expectancy of around 90 years. The neighborhood, which has a median income of around $100,000, is host to numerous amenities such as three hospitals and a branch campus of Northwestern University. Just eight miles away in Englewood, however, where the population is essentially all black, “life expectancy is just 60 [years].” In contrast to Streeterville, which is one of Chicago’s safest neighborhoods, Englewood saw “more than 4,800 shootings” between 2000 and 2017. Just eight miles away from each other, Englewood and Streeterville are two completely different universes — one is almost exclusively white, and the other is almost exclusively Black. Though Englewood and Streeterville provide one of the most intense examples of racialized socioeconomic segregation within an American city, statistics show that there are patterns of intense disparities across the United States. Researchers at UC-Berkeley have found that “residents of highly segregated Black and Latinx neighborhoods, including white residents, have lower life expectancies, lower income, lower home values, and lower educational attainments.”
Baltimore provides a good illustration of this fact. The city is host to the infamous “Baltimore Butterfly,” wherein the East and West sides of the city are overwhelmingly Black, and a narrow corridor in the city center, that includes the area around Johns Hopkins, is almost entirely white. Both homicides and lower property values map very neatly onto mostly Black areas of the city. The fact that mostly Black areas of the city are more violent is no accident. Public health research has shown that “residential racial segregation” is associated with youth firearm violence in mostly Black areas because it exposes Black youth to risk factors for violence, such as systemic neighborhood disadvantages.
On a more fundamental level, however, de facto segregation has fractured America into two different worlds. Writer Ta-Nehisi Coates, who grew up in the mostly-Black and low-income West Baltimore, captured this perfectly when he remarked that “I came to understand that my country was a galaxy ... I knew that my portion of the American galaxy, where bodies were enslaved by a tenacious gravity, was Black and that the other, liberated portion was not.” What Coates captures through this line is how utterly different his world in West Baltimore was from the white world of suburban picket fences.
Moreover, according to The Guardian, Black Americans generally do not want to live in hyper-segregated neighborhoods like the one Coates’ described. Instead, they often want to live in neighborhoods that are about 50-50 Black and white in terms of race. However, very few neighborhoods like this exist. Instead, white racism still continues to prevent Black Americans from moving into mostly-white neighborhoods. For example, being unnecessarily harassed by the police has in part created an internalized feeling among many Black Americanss that they constantly have to be on their “best behavior” to avoid prejudices from white Americans.
This racism extends into policy today, even if policymakers are no longer using the word “segregation.” For instance, in 2014, the Town of Grosse Pointe Park, Michigan — an affluent suburb of Detroit that was 85% white (as compared to Detroit, which is 83% Black and has a median income of $24,440) — built literal road barriers on the boundary between itself and Detroit to prevent Detroiters from driving into Grosse Pointe Park. Ostensibly, these barriers were built to support the local farmers’ markets on the Grosse Pointe side. In practice, however, as Daniel Goldberg, a Professor in Africana Studies at Wayne State University in Detroit, noted, the barriers also served to “remove Black visibility” and therefore, “to make the area more attractive.”
Racialized socioeconomic segregation also has insidious effects for those on the “right side of the fence.” As I articulated in my prior article “Growing Up Segregated,” where I discussed my experiences growing up in a mostly upper-middle-class town that was 0.5% Black, growing up in a segregated area can heavily warp our expectations of what is normal. For me, this resulted in understanding Blackness solely as an abstract concept, which was immensely harmful because it stymied my empathy without me even realizing it until I came to Amherst.
This then gestures toward one of the main problems that comes with tackling racialized socioeconomic segregation: For those who are on the “right side of the fence,” it is generally only an abstract concept of happenings in a far-away place. Racialized socioeconomic segregation has led to a country where middle-class suburbanites never have to worry about whether they will be profiled by the police or be subject to violence on a walk. They send their children to high-quality schools, and take it all for granted. Racialized socioeconomic segregation has created a country where the privileged almost never have to interact with those with less privilege than themselves, and thus never develop empathy for them. That’s what makes it so insidious.
So, then, what should we do about this problem? A good first step is to begin to talk about segregation as a political problem, in and of itself. Kamala Harris did this in 2019, when, during the Democratic Party Presidential Debate, she remarked “that little girl was me” in reference to her experience with busing as a young girl in Berkeley. Rhetoric like this is a good first start, but fundamentally, we need to have a political shift and discuss integration and segregation as urgent political problems requiring urgent solutions.
There are a whole host of policy proposals that, if implemented, could help remedy racialized socioeconomic segregation. One of these would be constructing more affordable housing in affluent neighborhoods, as well as constructing more mixed-income housing developments and giving low-income renters more substantial vouchers so as to be able to rent in more neighborhoods. Furthermore, in the absence of legally permissible, court-imposed multi-district busing plans, school districts could create more programs similar to METCO — a state program that helps achieve school integration by busing students from Boston and Springfield to public schools in neighboring communities. Fundamentally, erasing the “color-line” is going to require us to use a “radical imagination” and imagine a drastically different country than the one we live in today. That’s a tall task. However, we ought to remember that, like with all the lines we draw in the sand, we are also capable of erasing them.
Comments ()