AAS’s President and Vice President: An Opinion on the New Pass/Fail Policy
Managing Sports Editor Joey Supik ’27 and Staff Writer Charles Tufenkji ’28 grapple with the new pass/fail policy, arguing that this will make add-drop period chaotic and limit academic risk-taking, while highlighting the failure of the CEP to properly address the AAS’s concerns.
This past Friday, the faculty voted overwhelmingly in favor of the Committee on Educational Policy’s (CEP) proposed changes to the pass/fail policy, which we witnessed as Vice President of the Association of Amherst Students (AAS). We have two issues with the proposal. First, the actual proposal itself and the issues it allegedly aspires to address. Second, the complete disregard for students, not just AAS members, but all students, throughout the proposal process.
The proposal, brought forward by the current CEP chair, Winkley Professor of History and Political Economy Jen Manion, promises a return to some alleged golden age of pass/fail policy. Manion claims that the pass/fail policy’s purpose is to encourage educational risk-taking and exploration. Their proposed changes include the following: The total number of pass/fails a student could use during their time at Amherst goes from four to two, and students must declare pass/fails by the end of the add/drop period rather than the beginning of the reading period.
Forcing students to declare before they even fully experience a class will almost certainly create a hellish first two weeks for advisors and students, between approving changes to schedules and getting signatures for pass/fail forms. In addition, no one knows how a class will turn out immediately, even if students know the professor or have heard things about a specific course — and they certainly will not know enough by the end of the second week to declare a pass/fail. As one member in the faculty meeting cited, most students submit pass/fails in the last third of the semester. Any pass/fail decision requires time and effort to review the syllabus, talk with the professor, and see how the class goes in the first few weeks. Nothing about this new change will encourage these conversations; it will only rush them, if they happen at all.
The main issue with the policy, however, is that it doesn’t achieve its aspired goals: educational risk-taking and exploration. Currently, students are expected to put in their best work to receive a satisfactory grade, until the point at which they declare pass/fail. After that point, students’ standards of work can be much lower to achieve that satisfactory grade, or, in this case, a pass.
Moving the declaration period for pass/fail will now immediately lower the standards that students have to meet in order to succeed in a pass/failed course. Students will now be aware that the highest possible grade they can achieve is a pass, which may discourage them from putting in their best effort.
Moreover, decreasing the total number of pass/fails available doesn’t achieve more educational risk-taking. Even assuming that the policy’s change in declaration period succeeds in their goal, the change in total pass/fail options simply decreases the amount of times we can make use of this risk-taking opportunity. If the goal is increasing educational exploration and curiosity, decreasing the opportunities to explore and be curious seems counterintuitive.
The new pass/fail system is not about intellectual curiosity. Most likely, this policy change is a way to essentially kill the pass/fail option softly, which, in essence, is just another grade-deflation tactic. If practically no one uses pass/fail options in the first two-thirds of a semester — likely because no one knows how a course goes until they actually go through most of it — then this new policy will simply diminish almost all use of pass/fail. With less safeguarding around intellectual experimentation, this new policy will create further student anxiety, poorer grades, and a riskless campus culture.
Beyond that, Manion and the CEP’s members disregarded the opinion of the AAS and, by extension, all students, in handling the proposal. Manion disregarded all invitations to speak to AAS about this policy proposal, leaving the student senate out of the conversation, except for our three CEP members, whom the CEP consulted in individual meetings. However, that doesn’t equate to the public forum that we host in our AAS meetings for more students’ voices and opinions. Any significant student feedback was thus eliminated before it could have even been considered.
Our subjective feedback as students aside, not having the CEP at our meeting highlighted another, and more important, issue: The inability to fully understand their explanation behind the change. While we did get to hear the basics of the proposed policy changes from our CEP student members, the AAS simply couldn’t understand the full picture behind the policy changes, which severely diminished the quality of questions the senators could ask. Speaking to the AAS is not just a process to hear students’ feedback, but explaining how a proposed change fits within the college’s big picture. If the CEP had sent a faculty member to speak with us, the AAS might have felt more at ease once hearing the change’s rationale and long-term goals. Even though some members may have still disagreed with the change, they would have better understood the proposer’s perspective and reasoning.
The AAS’s executive board and CEP members attended the faculty meeting on Friday, at which we learned prior that Manion would present on the proposed changes to the pass/fail policy. Manion began the presentation by emphasizing the current policy’s downfalls in relation to intellectual curiosity. They cited data showing how STEM and humanities majors who used the pass/fail option were more likely to use it in courses of their respective disciplines, which deviates from the pass/fail policy’s intended purpose of incentivizing academic exploration. Manion was very particular about which data to highlight, ignoring the fact that only 10% of pass/failing arts majors used them in arts courses, or the more even distribution among the social sciences. It also doesn’t account for the breadth of courses within each discipline. Russian, Black studies, and classics courses are wildly different in teaching style and content — yet, they’re all listed as humanities. Simply saying that humanities students mostly pass/fail humanities courses fails to account for the sheer diversity of classes that they could be experimenting with.
The next major point of the presentation included going over the recent history of the pass/fail policy — to achieve this point, they used a Coca-Cola analogy. Manion compared the proposed change to the policy as the original, “classic Coke that we all know and love.” The current policy — and a past version that closely resembles it — were compared to “Coke II” and “New Coke". The purpose was to compare the greatness and desirability of the proposed change (“classic Coke”) to the failure and disgusting nature of the current pass/fail policy (“Coke II”).
The faculty discussion that followed the presentation was shocking. Immediately afterward, a former CEP chair spoke in favor of the proposed policy, restating that the current policy, which was adopted during their tenure as chair, was a failure. The class deans spoke next, pushing for greater accessibility for course withdrawal — specifically moving the last day to submit the withdrawal form from the tenth week to a much later point in the semester. This proposed change would greatly increase student accessibility to withdraw from courses in light of the pass/fail changes. We’re grateful that the class deans proposed this, since many students may be worried about no longer being able to use pass/fails to avoid poor grades on their transcripts due to extenuating circumstances. However, that was the end of all constructive feedback for the presentation and proposal. There were only around two or three other faculty members who spoke up, not voicing dissent but raising smaller points. The entire discussion lasted only about three or so minutes, then the faculty decided to vote on the proposal, which they overwhelmingly supported.
The entire affair was fairly easy for the CEP’s proposal. Following the misrepresented data on pass/fails by discipline and the coke analogy surrounding one of the college’s most important educational policies, the majority of faculty were immediately in support without question. No one objected or asked significant questions about the proposal’s potential effect on students. From the President and Vice President’s perspectives, as people who monitor and lead a space very similar to the faculty meeting, it is odd that there was zero public pushback or hesitation.
The dismissive attitude toward something that students care about, and the lack of shared information about the proposed policy before, during, and now after it was presented to the faculty and voted upon, is unconducive to the Amherst spirit. This is especially relevant when considering the other issues that lacked student input, like the events that led to the Community Advisors unionization efforts. We’d also like to believe that this has no relation to the various grade-deflation policies enacted across the college, which are not explicitly stated on course syllabi and departmental websites.
Moreover, we’d like to show appreciation for the countless other faculty members and administrators who have shown interest and met with the AAS to discuss important issues surrounding the college. The most recent example was on Monday, when Vice President and Dean of Admission & Financial Aid Matt McGann, Dean of Admission & Financial Aid Dale Hendricks, and Professor of Chemistry and FCAFA Chair Mark Marshall met with the AAS to debrief us on conversations surrounding the test-optional policy in admissions. Regardless of the potential outcome of such conversations much later on in the year, we are extremely grateful that they engaged with us through discussion and addressed student concerns and questions without reservation. We are also thankful for all those who spoke to the AAS before them, and we are looking forward to the meetings with administrators and faculty to come. We appreciate all the relationships we have in Student Engagement and Leadership, Student Affairs, and all over the college, with whom we hope to continue collaborating. We are also grateful for the opportunity to attend the faculty meeting in the first place; the intimate faculty-student relationship is the Amherst spirit in action.
An institution that claims to value its students so much should seek student voices, whether through the AAS or other avenues of student leadership, instead of sneaking around students’ backs on such prominent discussions. There comes a time, not necessarily now, that these issues pile up on one another without any recognition or resolution. Civil disobedience is in Amherst’s and this country’s soul, and while we hope future conversations will avoid such public displays of dissent, we all must have the spirit to recognize when it’s necessary to speak up for ourselves and future students at the college. If we continue allowing ourselves to be ignored, there is nothing to stand between us and future offenses, letting us all lower the standards of faculty and administration-student relations.
Comments ()